
One day famed game designer Raph Koster awoke to discover that his classic book, A Theory of Fun, had been turned into a plug-in for ChatGPT. Which was somewhat strange, because Raph Koster had not authorized his book to become a named discourse in ChatGPT. In fact, he only found out about the plug-in because it showed up on Google/Google Alerts.
So his immediate reaction was an ambivalent, "Uh…"
I located the creator of the plug-in. Who as it turns out, was a game developer and educator in Asia. And his specific reaction was: "😱😱😱"
He told me the plug-in was created for a game design course he's teaching, and he was thinking about incorporating queries about games through ChatGPT for it. He chose Raph's book, he explained, because it was small enough to fit into ChatGPT. (He also incorporated writings by fellow game designers Marc LeBlanc and Nicole Lazzaro.)
In any case, he added, the plug-in was only meant as an experiment and wasn't intended to be published. (I am therefore not linking to it nor listing his name.)
While this specific instance seems to have been an innocent mistake, it's also an early warning sign of a future trend: Well-known authors' works ingested into ChatGPT and other LLMs without their permission, but still represented as their work and thoughts.
As for Raph, he has ambivalent thoughts about the experience, and what it means for the future of copyright, and his own work:
(more…)